How to Spot a Sleeper Hit Before It Takes Off

In today’s crowded publishing landscape, blockbuster books dominate headlines—but savvy booksellers know that the real magic often lies in the quiet surprises: sleeper hits. These are the titles that start with modest buzz and unexpectedly catch fire through word-of-mouth, media coverage, or social media virality. For indie bookstores, spotting a sleeper hit early can mean more than just strong sales—it can build loyalty with customers who rely on your store for unique recommendations they won’t find everywhere else.

So how can indie booksellers catch lightning in a bottle before the rest of the market catches on?

‍

📖 1. Watch the Early Buzz—Beyond the Bestseller Lists

Sleeper hits rarely start on the bestseller charts. Instead, they creep in through enthusiastic handselling, TikTok mentions, local book clubs, or starred reviews in trade journals.

What to do:

• Scan trade publications like Publishers Weekly, Booklist, and Kirkus for glowing early reviews on debut or under-the-radar titles.

• Use ipage and NetGalley to read early feedback from booksellers, librarians, and educators.

• Check social media hashtags like #booktok and #bookstagram regularly to see which lesser-known books are gaining momentum organically.

‍

‍

🔍 2. Use Your Sales Data (and Ours) to Spot Movement

One of the strongest indicators of a sleeper hit is small, consistent sales growth across multiple stores or markets—often before mainstream recognition kicks in.

‍What to look for:

• Look for week-over-week increases in orders of titles that weren’t heavily promoted. That subtle uptick could signal a sleeper.

• Explore category-level trends (e.g., gothic fantasy, rom-coms with millennial protagonists, immigrant family sagas) to find breakout potential in a niche.

‍

‍

🤝 3. Trust the Indie Community

Sleeper hits often become indie darlings before they become household names.

Look for:

• Indie Next List picks with multiple bookseller quotes.

• Titles featured in regional bookseller association newsletters (GLIBA, NAIBA, SIBA, etc.).

• Recommendations from other bookstores in your ARC swaps or peer Slack groups.

Don’t underestimate the power of an early believer. If booksellers across the country are excited, that passion often trickles into national attention.

‍

‍

✍️ 4. Look for Publisher Positioning Clues

Sometimes publishers quietly signal confidence in a title even without a major marketing campaign.

Clues to watch for:

• High initial print run for a debut author

• Inclusion in seasonal mailers or digital catalogs

• Significant ARC distribution without big ad spend

• Comparisons to recent bestsellers or comp titles with known sales trajectories

If a publisher is printing 10,000+ copies for a debut with little fanfare, there’s probably internal buzz behind the scenes.

‍

‍

🛠️ 5. Use Your Ingram Tools to Act Fast

When a sleeper hit starts to move, timing is everything. Being ready to restock quickly or expand your inventory can give your store a key edge.

Pro tips:

• Sign up for Ingram marketing emails that announce titles you want to watch.

• Use Publisher Direct programs for restocks with shorter lead times.

• Check Print on Demand availability for small-press titles that may become sleeper hits.

‍

‍

📚 Examples of Sleeper Hits We’ve Seen Rise:

• The Midnight Library by Matt Haig — grew slowly through word of mouth and became a surprise bestseller

• Before the Coffee Gets Cold by Toshikazu Kawaguchi — a quiet translation that built a cult following

• Remarkably Bright Creatures by Shelby Van Pelt — a debut novel that took off in indie circles before hitting national charts

‍

‍

Final Thought: Bet on Passion, Not Just Hype

The beauty of indie bookselling is your power to champion the books you believe in. If a book resonates with your staff, if a few customers keep recommending it, if it feels like a gem—pay attention. That could be the moment a sleeper starts to wake up.

And when it does, Ingram’s here to help you stock up, stay agile, and keep those shelves full.

‍

‍

‍

‍